Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The linked-to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Chinese_milk_scandal was way more scandalous.

When bought in bulk, milk isn’t priced by the liter because it is too easy to water it down. Instead, it is priced by kilograms of protein.

Measuring protein is hard, so they measure nitrogen instead (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kjeldahl_method#Conversion_fac..., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumas_method#Advantages_and_li...). Melamine (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melamine) is cheap, rich in nitrogen, and, unfortunately, poisonous.



This scandal is the reason Dutch supermarkets still limit the amount of baby formula that can be bought per customer, so many Chinese trying to buy up large amounts that there was a risk many stores would run out.


Hong Kong even restricts export of baby formula (and smugglers are regularly arrested on the border to mainland).


I always wonder why they don't just order more from the factory and sell to the Chinese? (Or raise prices.)

Why don't they want to make more money?


From what I know, it is because of export control and regulation.

Nutricia, the Dutch milk powder company, cannot easily sell Dutch milk powder to China because import/export regulations don't easily allow them to do so. So they opened a store in China. But because of Chinese food regulations they cannot use the original formula. But consumers distrust the Chinese store because the formula has been altered. So people keep buying "real" Dutch milk powder fron smugglers.


I don't know if the factories are manufacturing enough, or capable of ramping up to do so. It's a huge increase in demand. I heard of similar problems in Australia.


Sure, but why not just charge more and sell to the highest bidders?


Because it's baby formula, produced here, and rather vital. Government is _not_ going to stand idly by if it disappears from stores because some other country bids more.


It's called "civilisation"


Civilization is to deny milk powder to people who want to pay for it, just because they are from another side of a border?


They went hard on the justice atleast:

"Two people were executed, one given a suspended death penalty, three people receiving life imprisonment, two receiving 15-year jail terms,and seven local government officials, as well as the Director of the Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine (AQSIQ), being fired or forced to resign"


Stupidly enough, that scandal was partially to blame on the government price caps on milk.

Farmers' inputs were getting more expensive but they were prevented from raising prices. So some farmers were more likely to resort to such poisonous fraud.

Of course, the foreign milk products they import these days are even more expensive.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: