Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

All orbits should 'eventually' decay as more matter comes in and perturbs the orbit. Stability is a matter of how quickly it decays, not if it decays.


My understanding is that photons are uniquely unstable. By virtue of traveling at a constant (the speed of light), they lack the self-regulating orbital mechanics of matter (where going deeper into the gravity well speeds you up, and going farther away slows you down.)

Dealing with spherical cows, before accounting for drag, you can describe the possible space for valid orbits as a volume, and you could describe the bounds of the velocity vector via another volume, for all positions and velocities at those positions that describe - at least on paper - mathematically perfectly stable orbits.

Dealing with a photonic cow, before accounting for drag, you can describe the possible space for mathematically stable orbits as not a volume but an area - the surface of a sphere. The velocity vector has a very specific magnitude (c), and a very limited range of possible directions (exactly perpendicular to the normal of the sphere's surface). The shape you would use to describe the bounds of this velocity vector have 0 volume, 0 area. It only has a length.

Both cows can be further perturbed by drag, tidal effects, non-point gravity sources, etc. to further worsen the problem. Individual collisions with particles of space dust will push the spherical cow from one mathematically stable orbit to another, until eventually they add up enough to most likely deorbit it. Individual collisions with particles of space dust will instead take the photonic cow from one mathematically unstable orbit to another, with a decent chance of it ending up on an escape trajectory instead.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: