Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't think morality is about empathy. I think the "how would you feel if..." arguments are bad. So I wouldn't consider this a significant problem, if true.

I don't know if you've read through my app, but I think you will find it's consistent with my views in general, and thoroughly fails to advocate empathy.

I would be more inclined to point out that if there is a disagreement about a cookie, it is in everyone's interests to use a truth seeking process to find out the right thing to do. Then everyone can win. With fighting, someone loses, and it will sometimes be you, and even if you win the other guy uses his creativity against you instead of cooperatively.



I think most of morality can be learned or deduced by applying empathy. Morality and empathy are closely related.

Like the Golden Rule, for example. Do I like being slapped? If no, don't slap. Do I like to be stolen from? If no, don't steal from others. And so on. Empathy towards others goes a long way towards being moral -- even if one has to "fake" it at times.


i'm not sure i like your basis for morality.

by your standards, if i like being slapped is it moral for me to slap others?


No, his "basis for morality" does not say that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: