Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I always think this sums it up well:

    > Current state makes it very hard to mange/search/fork/open-issues etc
    > especially for newcomers,
    > please move the project to github so we can have nice disussions
    > forks/prs etc goodness.

    No.  Never.  Github is proprietary communications tool which requires
    users to accept a terms of service and login.  That gives power and
    influence to a single entity (and a for-profit organization at that).

    Contributing to unicorn is *socially* as easy as contributing to git or
    the Linux kernel.  There is no need to signup for anything, no need to
    ever touch a bloated web browser.

    The reason I contribute to Free Software is because I am against any
    sort of lock-in or proprietary features.  It absolutely sickens me to
    encounter users who seem to be incapable of using git without a
    proprietary communications tool.
https://bogomips.org/unicorn-public/20140801213202.GA2729@dc...


Linus seems to have a different take on OSS than most OSS warriors. I don't think he sees proprietary software as 'evil' or OSS as morally superior. I get the impression he just thinks OSS will be better in quality. Depending on the contributors, which is why he doesn't want or need endless numbers of average devs contributing to his baby.

I think his point about Tridgell's actions with BK reverse engineering were right, and El Reg was playing the OSS warrior card. It looks to me like Tridgell was trying to create a way to steal BK metadata - BK specifically required you to have a license to get that data.

OSS warriors annoy me as much as SJWs do, and seem just as narrow minded.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: