Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Are you talking about everything being an Electron app?


Well, I'm talking about mobile, so the Electron model isn't quite applicable. But sort of, yes. Except without the overhead of each app bundling it's own entire browser runtime.


Progressive web apps actually run in the browser (any modern browser), whereas Electron runs its own copy of Chromium and Node.js, which is why you see the bloat.


It's all about trade-offs though, right?

Compared to a native app web apps are bloated, slow, have foreign UIs, and are power hungry. On a desktop machine, it probably doesn't matter, but for anything battery powered it does. I'll choose a native app any day of the week over a web app.


When I see the word Electron, I just don't install the "app." I am convinced that the 3MB winamp does just a good of a job being a media player as the stupid "electron" "app" that takes 20x as much RAM.


20? try 200




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: