Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Olive also is cross-platform app (as use Qt5) for Linux/macOS/Windows/etc.

Olive distributed for Linux as AppImage too[0] ;-)

> OpenShot is another free (also GPLv3 as Olive) video editor for Windows/Linux/Max using the portable AppImage format

FTR, AppImage is portable package only for Linux, in same way as DMG is portable package for macOS, or EXE is portable package for Windows.

[0] https://github.com/olive-editor/olive/releases/tag/continuou...



Thanks for your hard work and the clarifications.

Indeed from a 10,000ft view the projects share some good stuff.

As @prokoudine pointed out in his other article [1] (linked at the top of this article), Jonathan Thomas from Openshot will be "100% full time working on OpenShot" in 2019, which is exciting with now both Olive and OpenShot working on making great video editing software.

What are your opinions comparing Olive to OpenShot, maybe more in broader terms (history/goals/manpower/roadmap/pro features coming up/...) instead of current feature comparison, since you guys appear to move very fast (but I also expect OpenShot to do some great stuff too in 2019). You must have surveyed the field before starting and have wonderful insights about the two (also @pedrokost comments regarding problems in OpenShot for bigger projects worries me, and Olive seem to beat Openshot there) and seen some shortcomings to decide to make your own.

Maybe @prokoudine will produce another interesting article about that?

--

[1] http://libregraphicsworld.org/blog/entry/the-quest-for-susta...


> Thanks for your hard work and the clarifications.

Please, tell all thanks to @OliveTeam (Olive devs) via Twitter[0] and Patreon[1] ;)

I'm NOT developer of Olive; I'm just Olive user & tester.

[0] https://twitter.com/oliveteam

[1] https://www.patreon.com/olivevideoeditor


@app4soft is not the Olive developer (nor am I :))

Shotcut development is self-funded since 2018, so that makes three projects.

I don't see myself seriously comparing OpenShot to Olive. They are vastly different, in my opinion. The way I see it, Olive is being streamlined for prosumer/pro work. Hence all the editing tools, advanced keyframes UI, graph editor etc. — things I don't expect OpenShot to have.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: