Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is a sad situation. But the article doesn't support the title. Because I only see one time point. And "vanishing" requires comparison.

A few decades ago, at what was arguably the peak of the US middle class, relatively few adult married women worked outside the home. But of course, they did work. It's just that they didn't get paid.

Or rather, they got paid through sharing their husbands' income. What's happened since is that both partners often work, but aggregate inflation-adjusted income (aka household income) has stagnated. Maybe even declined.

Anyway, the point is that, a few decades ago, maybe 30%-40% of workers earned nothing. So to get meaningful results, you need to look at aggregate household income over time. Including both partners, and children. And you also need to net out childcare expenses.

Also, I note that TFA relies on W2 data. So what about consultants, whose income is reported on 1099s? But maybe they're a minor factor, and can be ignored.

And finally, it's my impression that executive incomes are typically capped at a $million or so. With the rest paid as stock options and such.



One problem with the aggregate household income being added up is there isn't an accounting for worked hours (basically doubling the hours by having 2 people working for a company).

A different, but simple comparison would be to take minimum wage in 1968 ($1.60), adjust for inflation ($11.62 - 2017) and then compare to our current minimum wage ($7.25). So had minimum wage been tied to inflation, it would be right around $12/hr right now.


Arguably you're not doubling the hours. Because decades ago, women worked at home, but weren't paid.


And then you should also factor in the value of the work women did at home, and weren't paid for. Because they're now having to pay someone else to do that work, which reduces the effective income gain of them working.


Yes, very true. And that makes it worse.

I do think that the US middle class is shrinking. But there's a lot more involved than TFA addresses.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: