Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is you who are mixing up inner and outer. The EU is an open border place (or at least, the Schengen area is) for those who reside there. For some other countries' nationals to enter a visum is required. The EU was never about 'open borders' at the boundaries, in fact there are a lot of requirements on the boundary states and they get compensation for that.


The EU was never about 'open borders' at the boundaries

That's exactly what I wrote. Open borders as an idea is about global free movement. Schengen on the other hand is just a bigger kind of fenced area, international agreement simplifying travel and trade for citizens of participating countries. When @cojxd asked "For whom is open borders a dream?" I'm pretty sure it was meant as an idea/ideology. Because, if someone agrees to lift this border, but not that - there's simply nothing to discuss. It's a kind of position acceptable for almost everyone.


> Because, if someone agrees to lift this border, but not that - there's simply nothing to discuss.

You're pretty wrong about that. Borders are a nuisance, and lifting all of them is a good long term goal to have. But in the intermediary we can only move so fast. Saying that you don't want to discuss lifting individual borders as long as we are not lifting all borders is like saying you don't want to make a first step as long as we're not agreeing to walk all the way to the destination. That's not how societal change is achieved, it is achieved one step at the time, usually without lofty long term goals and every border that falls is one more step along the way towards open borders and should be applauded.


don’t all countries in the EU have a 3 month stay period after which you have to register as a resident? i’m a european that has lived in multiple EU countries and the hassle of moving between them is more or less the same as moving across the globe.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: