Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Just an ancillary point: this highlights that free access to group messaging apps makes it much harder than before to suppress facts about what has happened somewhere. Especially if there's video. The Iran regime of 1990 would have had a much easier time keeping this mistake under wraps.

I think the whole "fake news" and related propaganda strategies we see in the West are what happens when people in power try to adapt to this new reality, by attacking at the weak spots of the new information infrastructure.



Yes. Rather than attempt to suppress it in the West, we'd see a lot of conflicting reports, allegations of fake news, unrelated smear attempts, questioning of loyalties, and attempts to arrest whistleblowers.

The US never did admit liability for shooting down an Iranian jet in similar circumstances: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655


There's a gap, between admitting to downing a plane and "admitting liability" for it, in which the US places its downing of Flight 655.

But the parallel you would need to draw here is of the former: admitting to downing the plane.


For flight 655, while they never admitted guilt, they did settle paying the victim's families "ex-gratia" a non-negligible sum. While it is not the same as directly admitting you are responible, espcecially to the victims, for most intents and purposes that counts as an admition in my books.


After the US commander of the ship murdered 290 people on flight 655, he was given a Legion of Merit.

Two sets of rules.


Throwing the word "murder" about like this is an abuse of language. Nobody, not even the Iranians, ever suggested that the crew of the USS Vincennes intended to kill civilians. The crew appears to have exercised piss-poor diligence, but it's universally recognized that they thought they were firing on a military aircraft.


[flagged]


Personal attacks will get you banned here. Also, can you please not post unsubstantive comments generally?

The intended spirit of this site is described in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. Would you please review those rules and post in keeping with them?


There is a great observation in one of the Bellingcat podcasts on MH17.

Russia no longer denies facts. Instead they go all postmodern:

“what are facts anyway? What is truth?”

I guess Trump does this too to an extent. Except he has the press in his neck to call him out.


Russia still denies facts. Period.

This topic is about Iran.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: