Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I regularly hear a friend complain about BS like this and variants. "Why did adding a button take a week, it's just a button?!" is also very popular. Not sure what's worse, that or the recurring "that element should be 1px to the left, drop everything you're working on and fix it asap"...


A funny side-effect of this that I ran into: customers who went to tortuous lengths to avoid requesting a new page or button, because they’d had that past experience of ‘just a button’ taking 2 weeks. They still wanted all the new functionality, but glued onto the existing pages/buttons because they thought it would save time! An interesting misunderstanding :)


See that all the time. It’s why you need proper requirements gathering, to get past that kind of thing.


Try changing the colour and getting told it isn't the same shade of red as the drawings presented by the designer on his PDF presentation.


"It looks different on my iPad, we need it to look exactly the same everywhere"

No, No you don't.


I mean, that's totally reasonable if that's the spec (not to mention hopefully trivial to fix).

Now if there's 5 drawings with different colors, or asking "what color do you want it?" leads to a 5-week email chain...


Oh, that's actually also pretty reasonable (sorta): https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=44872

I discovered that bug report after our designer noticed at a glance walking behind me (I use Firefox) that the colors on our site were far darker than she intended, somewhere around 2017-2018 (that bug was opened in 2010).


Yeesh my blood started to boil just reading that.

I've left companies because of devs like that. People who just stand in the way of getting the software to do the correct thing. I do not understand what makes these people tick.


that's totally reasonable if that's the spec

I don't think you grok what's happening. Some middle manager sees a shade of red on his screen in a PDF, and the dev is expected to reproduce the content in that shade of red. There are simply too many variables.

Even if you have access to the PDF, the red will often be rendered differently by the browser than it is by the PDF engine.

I've had middle managers tell me to "fix" a web site because the colors looked different on his office CRT than it did on the laptop screen of a person in another building.

trivial to fix

Everything is trivial when someone else has to fix it.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: