Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The Dole gave us Harry Potter, you know. It also gave us Oasis. I'm sure that Britons can give you lots more examples.

Given that most creative output comes from a very small number of people, releasing even a tiny fraction of those people from the basic drudgery of life should result in a cultural explosion.

I would even argue that it would significantly help our current political problems. A lot of political discourse is driven by people who have unstructured idle time--retired or unemployed. UBI would allow people who currently have to struggle to support themselves to engage with the political system.



People on welfare still have the motivation, the need to improve their lot. UBI, being so… universal, would rob us of that motivation.

Besides, don’t artists need the struggle to create? Isn’t best art born of pain and suffering? Isn’t the artist soul a tortured one?


I believe the answer is no.

I dont have sources but I've read studies of the creative output of people who only do work when feeling inspired creative motivated and whatnot vs those who do purely out of discipline and habit. And even same people in different moods. And there is no discernable difference in output. Its a feel good assumption but you don't need any of those things to create beautiful things


It's even worse. Studies went down this rabbit hole and found that those who simply produce also produce better than those who wait to be "inspired".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: