Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Choice is fundamental to rejection, and rejection is fundamental to counter culture.

Most Westerners 'reject' Marxism, but that's not because we choose not to live in Marxist societies, it's because none exist that would take a Westerner in.

"Choice" is very often an expression of circumstance, and I would again argue the emphasis on wealthy white people choosing to become hippies in the 1960s has really skewed peoples idea of what a counterculture is.



I heartily disagree. Choice is central to rejection. Someone born blind by circumstance is not rejecting vision. Some who blinds themselves or refuses restorative treatment is rejecting vision.

Re Marxism, Most people reject Marxism by not desiring it or desiring to implement it. They have the choice to advocate for it or vote for Marxists, but in general do not. However, some do choose it and there is a small US communist party.


But surely you agree that those people who vote for it do not live in Marxist societies/cultures?

They live in cultures completely counter to Marxism. In practice they reject Marxism because they do not live its principles.


I dont think that constitutes rejection of Marxism. If you do everything within your power to bring about communism, are you not rejecting it.

If there is more in your power to do and you choose not to, then that is rejection.

This comes back to rejection being a matter of choice.

Does a slave reject freedom, because they dont have it and cant obtain it? Is a cancer patient who cant afford treatment rejecting treatment? Of course we wouldnt say these things because rejection implies option and choice.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: