Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If the mother is not a us citizen is she entitled to counsel? Or entitled to anything else? Curious to know to what parts of US law apply to non citizens and what parts do not.


In noncriminal matters such as deportations, there's no right to counsel at public expense. The broader rights to due process of law and habeas corpus have generally been held by the courts to apply to immigration detention and deportation, and people are certainly free to hire counsel at their own expense in such proceedings.

It gets tricky when a deportation is completed before a court can hear the case. Attempting to prevent a detainee from communicating their location and situation to someone who could bring a legal action on their behalf doesn't appear to be explicitly illegal, but it's certainly an attempt to subvert due process and probably ought to be illegal.


> In noncriminal matters

It’s interesting how the administration always talks about these people being here illegally and that they’re all criminals but then leverages the non-criminal aspect of the proceedings to their advantage.


I agree with the substance of your point. I'd argue that it is less "interesting" and quite horrifying to be on the receiving end!


Yes, the sixth amendment is very clear on this.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: