Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
The Tech Industry Doesn't Understand Consent (soatok.blog)
13 points by ColinWright 9 months ago | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments


Oh they understand consent. They also want to make people accidentally give consent or to mislead them into consent. Their entire business model relies on exploitation of people - and consent is merely a roadblock in exploitation efforts.


> They also want to make people accidentally give consent or to mislead them into consent.

Which is a logical impossibility. You can't be tricked or accidentally give consent. Consent is an informed, intentional decision. Anything else doesn't count.

But I do agree: the tech industry understands consent just fine, it's just fundamentally opposed to the idea.


> Consent is an informed, intentional decision. Anything else doesn't count.

From a legal perspective, consent is merely a database entry with t on it for that user_id.

There is a big difference between English language consent and tech company manufactured consent.


Yes, I'm talking about actual consent, not the legal fiction of it.


I would say this in a different way, which is that they have an understanding that data handling consent in any sort of way that’s fair to customers is not a legal requirement to operate a tech business in the US.

If you were starting a business and nobody requires you to do a specific action, what’s your incentive to do it? Especially when customers will come your way either way.


Considering the CEO of Automatic is a huge a-hole, I'm hardly surprised.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: