Those who are interested in this subject and want to discuss it, you may be interested in seeing the points - good and bad - that have been made on previous occasions that this has been submitted. Here are a few previous discussion:
Discussions like this can be of value, and no doubt some of the newer people on HN may have points to add. OTOH, many points will already have been made, so seeing the past discussions may be of benefit.
Well, to be honest, I have deep-scripted accessing HN, but I tend only to use it when doing big data crunching on trends and similar. When providing cross-references I've usually just put the IDs - actually counting points, comments and age is something I've not done for a while.
Don't think I'll bother again, I get enough grief and hate-mail just from trying to point people at earlier conversations.
I really appreciate it when earlier conversations are pointed to. (The additional points/comments/age numbers are wonderful, too, if you feel up to providing them.)
I wonder if a bot could be written to automate this? There are lots of horrible reasons one could have for writing a HN comment bot, so I'm hesitant to even suggest it, but this seems like a really useful/good bot.
Actually, I can't tell you how many times a HN comment like yours has turned me on to an ultra-valuable related discussion that I would never have seen or thought to look for.
So don't let negative comments (perceived or actual) speak for us silent appreciaters!
I won't post the unpleasant emails - I'd have to go and find them and I'm not inclined to re-read them. You can read some dissenting opinions, and a reasonably civilized discussion here:
Came here to post this, except I was going to suggest it be built into HN itself and be in a section at the top of the comment page, perhaps between the link and the comment box. A way to suggest/add the links to the box would be good too (maybe mods + the submitter could have control of which links show up via this system)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=232192 (indiangeek.net) 75 points 4 years ago 33 comments
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=554338 (indiangeek.net) 83 points 3 years ago 33 comments
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1022394 (indiangeek.net) 67 points 2 years ago 40 comments
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1949915 (starling-software.com) 155 points 1 year ago 106 comments
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2823912 (indiangeek.net) 12 points 1 year ago 1 comments
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3434350 (starling-software.com) 2 points 9 months ago 0 comments
Discussions like this can be of value, and no doubt some of the newer people on HN may have points to add. OTOH, many points will already have been made, so seeing the past discussions may be of benefit.