Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Most likely, whoever produces and publishes the question sets changed the question for a new edition and did not notice that the new question also changed the answer.

In the previous edition it was probably something like "Marie works in a factory which makes cars; it takes her 10 minutes to finish two cars. How long will it take Marie to finish three cars?"

And the answer to that would be 15 minutes, and the reasoning in the answer (based on reducing fractions, which is what it's probably supposed to teach) would be correct.

But probably in the next edition the question changed from putting things together to cutting them apart, and the author/editor simply didn't realize that these are not interchangeable. The teacher, meanwhile, probably didn't look too closely at it, and simply applied the answer and reasoning supplied in the teaching materials for the question set.

None of which implies that the teacher can't do the math; rather, it implies systemic problems in the way the materials are produced and in the methods used by teachers to grade the work.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: